Thanks Thanks:  3
Likes Likes:  7
Results 1 to 2 of 2

Thread: 2006 Dodge RAM 3500 5.9L Cummins - Trans Won't Stay In 4th Gear?

  1. Top Of Page | #1
    MrJay's Avatar

    User Info Menu

    2006 Dodge RAM 3500 5.9L Cummins - Trans Won't Stay In 4th Gear?

    A non-diesel-specific mechanic recently told me there are many problems with my 5.9L, and one of them was that I'd need a new ECM because they saw some codes (I haven't seen any codes and they didn't share...yet).

    I had him replace a rear U-joint and the passenger upper+lower ball joints, and then I got the truck back as I did NOT have shifting issues before it went to him.

    Now it can't seem to stay in 4th gear even at 70mph, and the truck has 315k miles on the truck.

    Shifting Issue 1
    If I start slow from a dead stop (start rolling real slow with no load), I get what feels like a clutch shudders around 5-10mph (just barely after turning through a turn from a stop light).
    I back out of the accelerator, then throttle down on the accelerator at about 25-30%, and it picks up without that shudder.

    Shifting Issue 2
    It seems to shift through gears 1-3 without issues (48RE).
    However, I won't start thinking about 4th gear until I push it towards 50-55mph, and the tach is around 2800-3000.
    Once it jumps into 4th (even at 55+ mph) won't take long, and it downshifts to 3rd.

    I haven't been driving much with these issues. But I did take it down the hwy at 70mph, and it shifted to 4th around 55mph, but when I got to 70 and let up to cruise there, it downshifted into 3rd, and RPMs are WAY high.

    Troubleshooting 101
    I heard that some shifting issues might be due to a faulty TSS sensor, so for $35, I replaced that, but it didn't resolve the problem.
    Tranny oil level looks fine, and I have engine oil leaking out of the rear main seal because of crankcase pressure (I replaced the seal twice).
    I figured out the cause is that cylinder #2 has pressure loss and cylinder #1 is just behind it.
    It must be time to replace rings or more. But that's another issue.

    This is all stock, and the tranny was rebuilt about 80k miles ago, and the valve body springs were upgraded about 20k miles ago.

    I've had guys tell me it's an ECM or TCM issue, but not anyone who knows these 5.9L & 48RE systems.

    What are the thoughts of the community here?

    Does anyone have experience with this?

    Is it an ECM issue?

    Last edited by IGOTACUMMINS; 02-24-2023 at 01:56 PM.

  2. Thanks watersupply189, IGOTACUMMINS thanked for this post
  3. Top Of Page | #2
    I WILL STAND! AK Bob's Avatar

    User Info Menu

    Re: 2006 Dodge RAM 3500 5.9L Cummins - Trans Won't Stay In 4th Gear?

    Quote Originally Posted by MrJay View Post
    A non-diesel-specific mechanic recently told me there are many problems with my 5.9L, and one of them was that I'd need a new ECM because they saw some codes.

    I had him replace a rear U-joint and the passenger upper+lower ball joints, and then I got the truck back as I did NOT have shifting issues before it went to him.

    Now it can't seem to stay in 4th gear even at 70mph, and the truck has 315k miles on the truck.

    Shifting Issue 1
    If I start slow from a dead stop (start rolling real slow with no load), I get what feels like a clutch shudders around 5-10mph (just barely after turning through a turn from a stop light).
    I back out of the accelerator, then throttle down on the accelerator at about 25-30%, and it picks up without that shudder.

    Shifting Issue 2
    It seems to shift through gears 1-3 without issues (48RE).
    However, I won't start thinking about 4th gear until I push it towards 50-55mph, and the tach is around 2800-3000.
    Once it jumps into 4th (even at 55+ mph) won't take long, and it downshifts to 3rd.

    I haven't been driving much with these issues. But I did take it down the hwy at 70mph, and it shifted to 4th around 55mph, but when I got to 70 and let up to cruise there, it downshifted into 3rd, and RPMs are WAY high.

    Troubleshooting 101
    I heard that some shifting issues might be due to a faulty TSS sensor, so for $35, I replaced that, but it didn't resolve the problem.
    Tranny oil level looks fine, and I have engine oil leaking out of the rear main seal because of crankcase pressure (I replaced the seal twice).
    I figured out the cause is that cylinder #2 has pressure loss and cylinder #1 is just behind it.
    It must be time to replace rings or more. But that's another issue.

    This is all stock, and the tranny was rebuilt about 80k miles ago, and the valve body springs were upgraded about 20k miles ago.

    I've had guys tell me it's an ECM or TCM issue, but not anyone who knows these 5.9L & 48RE systems.

    What are the thoughts of the community here?

    Does anyone have experience with this?

    Is it an ECM issue?
    Hopefully, someone with 48RE experience will respond.

    Thinking the actual trouble codes may help them diagnose the issue.

    2014 RAM 3500 (Aisin) 3.73 4X4 Limited Crew Cab Long Bed DRW. Oil Bypass Filter, Fuel Filtration Kit, Cold Air Intake, City Diesel Actuator and 50 Gallon Aux Fuel Tank.

  4. Thanks IGOTACUMMINS thanked for this post
    Likes Corkey, watersupply189, IGOTACUMMINS liked this post

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •